N
National OrthodonticRegistry
AboutFor Practices
Practice loginRegister your practice
N
National OrthodonticRegistry
AboutFor Practices
Practice loginRegister your practice
Book OnlineCall

Tap to connect directly with this practice

  1. Home
  2. /Wisconsin
  3. /Verona Orthodontists
  4. /First Choice Dental- Orthodontics
Accepting new patients

First Choice Dental- Orthodontics

First Choice Dental offers orthodontic care including traditional braces and Invisalign for patients of all ages.

925 N Main St, Verona, WI 53593
4.5(28 reviews)
Call Now(608) 848-0820Book OnlineWebsiteDirections

About First Choice Dental- Orthodontics

Dr. Taylor's team often takes on patients transferring mid-treatment from other practices, sometimes finishing braces cases faster than the original timeline.

Reviews here often mention patients transferring in from another orthodontist, including one case where a switch after three years in braces led to completion within about a year under the new doctor. Invisalign and traditional braces both come up frequently, with several reviews noting timelines that beat initial estimates. Some reviews mention billing issues, including disputes over refunds and X-ray charges, and a few describe long waits or scheduling changes.

Summary of 24 patient reviews, October 2017–July 2026, updated September 2026

First Choice Dental offers orthodontic care including traditional braces and Invisalign for patients of all ages.

Services include free consultations with exams, x-rays, and treatment planning to address crooked teeth, crowded teeth, and misaligned bites.

Treatments offered

InvisalignInvisalignTraditional BracesTraditional BracesTMJ TreatmentTMJ Treatment
GuidesHow much does Invisalign cost? →Adult braces cost guide →Teen braces cost guide →

Who They Treat

First Choice Dental- Orthodontics provides orthodontic treatment for the following age groups:

Children
Ages 6–11
Teens
Ages 12–17
Adults
Ages 18+

Orthodontists at this office

provider
headshot

Dylan Handlin

NPI verified · no bio or photo on file

NPI VERIFIEDAccepting New Patients

Insurance accepted

11 plans listed
AetnaAmeritasCareingtonCignaDelta DentalDelta Dental PremierGuardianHumana
First Choice Dental- Orthodontics does not list Medicaid. Coverage varies by plan tier — confirm with the office before your first visit.

What patients say

Latest review 4 months ago

What patients praise

  • Several reviews describe transferring mid-treatment from another practice and finishing under Dr. Taylor's care, in one case much faster than expected.
  • Multiple reviews mention braces or Invisalign timelines that finished ahead of the original estimate.
  • A few reviews note young children leaving their first orthodontic visit in good spirits.

Things to know

  • A few reviews describe billing problems, including disputed refunds and an unexpected charge for X-ray copies.
  • Some reviews mention scheduling issues, such as long waits before a first appointment or turnover among orthodontists at the practice.

Who it suits

  • Patients transferring mid-treatment from another orthodontist
  • Families with multiple children in treatment at once
  • Young children starting orthodontic care

Doctors patients mention

  • Dr. Taylor · 6 reviews
Last 12 months
6 reviews
averaging 3.3★
Owner replies
31% of reviews
typically within 29 days
Reviews per month
2
Oct 2023Sep 2026
Reviews per month
Oct 20230
Nov 20230
Dec 20230
Jan 20240
Feb 20241
Mar 20242
Apr 20241
May 20240
Jun 20240
Jul 20240
Aug 20240
Sep 20240
Oct 20240
Nov 20240
Dec 20241
Jan 20250
Feb 20250
Mar 20252
Apr 20250
May 20250
Jun 20250
Jul 20250
Aug 20250
Sep 20250
Oct 20251
Nov 20250
Dec 20250
Jan 20260
Feb 20261
Mar 20260
Apr 20260
May 20262
Jun 20261
Jul 20261
Aug 20260
Sep 20260
Star ratings
  • 5★25
  • 4★1
  • 3★1
  • 2★0
  • 1★5
Average rating by year
  • 20174.5
  • 20185.0
  • 20195.0
  • 20205.0
  • 20215.0
  • 20225.0
  • 20235.0
  • 20243.4
  • 20253.7
  • 20263.0
1★5★
Treatments patients mention
  • Braces8
  • Invisalign / clear aligners6
What patients talk about
PraiseCriticism
  • The orthodontist8 / 2
  • Friendly staff6 / 2
  • Treatment results7 / 1
  • Clear explanations4 / 1
  • Treatment timeline3 / 2
  • Great with kids4
  • Scheduling & wait times2 / 2
  • Cost, insurance & financing0 / 4
What patients talk about
ThemePraiseCriticism
The orthodontist82
Friendly staff62
Treatment results71
Clear explanations41
Treatment timeline32
Great with kids40
Scheduling & wait times22
Cost, insurance & financing04

Advertisement

Claim your profile free to remove ads from this page.

Recent reviews from Google

4.5
28 reviews
Laurie Sango
Laurie Sango
2 months ago
“

Well since I have to take care of my teeth this place will do? Front desk doesn't want to be there. Everything takes forever. Overcharged $200 and I'm the one that noticed, they gave me a credit instead of a refund. All depends who you see: some people don't care you're there and some go above and beyond.

Review from Google

Angela Himegarner
Angela Himegarner
2 months ago
“

I have worked with Dr. Taylor and his fabulous team for two years. Today, I graduated!! They are so thoughtful, caring and professional. I appreciate Dr. Taylor's desire for perfection ;). I love my new smile and can't thank them enough!!!!

Review from Google

Jonathan Lawson
Jonathan Lawson
3 months ago
“

I’m very disappointed with my experience here. I moved to Florida in the middle of my Invisalign treatment and notified the office that I wanted to transfer my treatment to an orthodontist in Florida. At that time, I was told I would receive a refund of around $600. After moving, I followed up twice by phone because I never received the refund. Both times, they confirmed my address and told me they would send it. The refund never came. I never ended up finding a new orthodontist in Florida because my living situation there ended up being temporary. About a year later, I moved back to the Madison area and contacted them to see if I could continue treatment instead of pursuing the refund, since I still had the same Invisalign buttons attached and had not received treatment elsewhere. I was then told I would have to repay the full original cost of Invisalign because their system showed I had still been “receiving treatment” during that time, and because I had been unresponsive they would require full payment to continue treatment. They also told me the refund would only have applied if I had officially transferred my case to another orthodontist, but nobody ever explained that requirement to me when I originally informed them I was moving or during the two follow-up calls about my refund. They said that because their system considered me to still be “receiving treatment,” the 24-month treatment window had continued running, which meant I was now outside that window and no longer eligible for the refund either. I feel like there was a major lack of communication and follow-through throughout this process. Had the requirements and deadlines been clearly explained from the beginning, I would have handled things differently.

Review from Google

Megan
Megan
4 months ago
“

Our dental insurance changed between the consultation appointment and when we were to start treatments. As a result, the clinic wants to charge me $300.00 for copies of the X-rays to be sent to an in-network provider. Bonkers.

Review from Google

Kimbra
Kimbra
6 months ago
“

Dr. Kyle Taylor & Team are exceptional. My daughter's whole experience with braces was surprisingly pleasant. It's always welcoming and comforting entering the office with all of the wonderful staff.

Review from Google

Read all 28 reviews on Google →

Questions about this practice

What orthodontic treatments does First Choice Dental- Orthodontics offer?+
First Choice Dental- Orthodontics offers: Invisalign, Traditional Braces, TMJ Treatment.
Does First Choice Dental- Orthodontics accept dental insurance?+
First Choice Dental- Orthodontics accepts Aetna, Ameritas, Careington, Cigna, Delta Dental, and others.
Does First Choice Dental- Orthodontics offer free consultations?+
Yes, First Choice Dental- Orthodontics offers a free initial orthodontic consultation. Call (608) 848-0820 or book online to schedule.
Is First Choice Dental- Orthodontics accepting new patients?+
First Choice Dental- Orthodontics is currently welcoming new patients in Verona, WI. Call (608) 848-0820 or book online to schedule.
Where is First Choice Dental- Orthodontics located?+
First Choice Dental- Orthodontics is located at 925 N Main St. Get directions: https://maps.google.com/?cid=15647900778839608597&g_mp=CiVnb29nbGUubWFwcy5wbGFjZXMudjEuUGxhY2VzLkdldFBsYWNlEAIYBCAA
What are the office hours for First Choice Dental- Orthodontics?+
First Choice Dental- Orthodontics office hours: Mon 7:00 AM–5:00 PM, Tue 7:00 AM–5:00 PM, Wed 7:00 AM–5:00 PM, Thu 7:00 AM–5:00 PM, Fri 7:00 AM–4:00 PM, Sat Closed–Closed, Sun Closed–Closed.
Does First Choice Dental- Orthodontics offer payment plans?+
Yes, First Choice Dental- Orthodontics offers flexible payment plans to make orthodontic treatment affordable.
Who are the orthodontists at First Choice Dental- Orthodontics?+
First Choice Dental- Orthodontics is staffed by Dylan Handlin.
What is the patient rating for First Choice Dental- Orthodontics?+
First Choice Dental- Orthodontics has a 4.5-star rating based on 28 patient reviews on Google.

Other First Choice Dental- Orthodontics locations

First Choice Dental- Madison Campus
1050 Regent St, Madison · 4.7 (329)
View →
First Choice Dental- Madison Downtown
621 S Park St, Madison · 4.7 (486)
View →

Research with AI

ChatGPTPerplexityClaude
925 N Main St
Verona, WI 53593
Get Directions
(608) 848-0820
firstchoicedental.com/services/orthodontics/overview/
Book Online
Open in Google Maps
Accepting new patients
Free Consultation
Payment Plans Available
Online Booking Available

Accessibility & Parking

Wheelchair Accessible Entrance
Wheelchair Accessible Parking
Wheelchair Accessible Restroom
CashCredit CardsDebit CardsContactless / NFCCareCredit
Mon7:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Tue7:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Wed7:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Thu7:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Fri7:00 AM – 4:00 PM
SatClosed
SunClosed

Social Profiles

Google reviews synced
SOURCED

Claim your listing to update info, add photos, and respond to reviews. Claimed profiles are ad-free.

Are you the owner? Claim this listing
Back to Verona Orthodontists

Nearby orthodontists in Verona

Within 4 miles

Dentistry for Madison

4.9 · (320) · Madison

✓ Free consult

Orthodontic Specialists of Madison - Verona

4.5 · (14) · Verona · 0.1 mi

✓ Board certified · AAO member

Advanced Orthodontics Of Wisconsin

4.4 · (81) · Madison · 4.4 mi

✓ Free consult

View all Verona orthodontists →
N
National OrthodonticRegistry

The nationwide directory for finding orthodontic care. 4,706+ practices across all 50 states.

Popular Cities

  • Los Angeles, CA
  • New York City, NY
  • Houston, TX
  • Chicago, IL
  • Phoenix, AZ
  • Miami, FL
  • Dallas, TX
  • Atlanta, GA

Browse by State

  • California
  • Texas
  • Florida
  • New York
  • North Carolina
  • Ohio
  • Arizona
  • Virginia
  • All states →

Discover

  • Find an Orthodontist
  • Invisalign
  • Cost Guides
  • Research
  • About Us
  • Contact

For Practices

  • Claim Your Practice
  • Verified Practice
  • Featured & Premium
  • Practice Login

© 2026 National Orthodontic Registry. All rights reserved.

PrivacyTermsllms.txt