N
National OrthodonticRegistry
AboutFor Practices
Practice loginRegister your practice
N
National OrthodonticRegistry
AboutFor Practices
Practice loginRegister your practice
Book OnlineCall

Tap to connect directly with this practice

  1. Home
  2. /Ohio
  3. /Worthington Orthodontists
  4. /A Winning Smile Orthodontics
AAO MemberAccepting new patients

A Winning Smile Orthodontics

A Winning Smile Orthodontics is a private practice specializing in orthodontic care for children, teens, and adults in the Worthington and Columbus, Ohio area.

7100 N High St #105, Worthington, OH 43085
5.0(105 reviews)
Call Now(614) 888-8070Book OnlineWebsiteDirections
A Winning Smile Orthodontics

About A Winning Smile Orthodontics

Expander cases and retainer checkups scheduled long after braces come off show up often in reviews, alongside praise for Dr. Catherine Scheurer McDevitt's handling of complex corrections.

Reviews often mention patients who transferred in partway through treatment elsewhere, along with retainer checkups scheduled well after braces come off to guard against relapse. Dr. Catherine Scheurer McDevitt is described as gentle and thorough, handling expander cases and more complicated corrections with confidence, and several reviewers describe teeth moving from noticeably misaligned to straight by the end of treatment. Parents also note that staff remember cases over long stretches of time and stay warm and patient even with several children in the family going through treatment.

Summary of 76 patient reviews, February 2013–July 2026, updated September 2026

A Winning Smile Orthodontics is a private practice specializing in orthodontic care for children, teens, and adults in the Worthington and Columbus, Ohio area.

Led by Dr. Catherine Scheurer McDevitt with over 30 years of experience, the practice offers traditional metal braces, ceramic braces, Invisalign, and early orthodontic treatment with personalized, one-on-one care.

Treatments offered

InvisalignInvisalignEarly TreatmentEarly TreatmentClear AlignersClear AlignersTraditional BracesTraditional BracesClear BracesClear BracesRetainersRetainersSelf-Ligating BracesSelf-Ligating Braces
GuidesHow much does Invisalign cost? →Clear aligner costs explained →Adult braces cost guide →

Who They Treat

A Winning Smile Orthodontics provides orthodontic treatment for the following age groups:

Children
Ages 6–11
Teens
Ages 12–17
Adults
Ages 18+

Technology & Equipment

A Winning Smile Orthodontics uses modern orthodontic technology to deliver precise, comfortable treatment.

3D Digital Scanning
Accelerated Treatment
TADs / Mini-Screws
accelerated ortho
TADs

Orthodontists at this office

provider
headshot

Dr. Catherine Scheurer McDevitt

NPI verified · no bio or photo on file

Lead OrthodontistNPI VERIFIEDAccepting New Patients

Insurance accepted

4 plans listed
AetnaDelta Dental Medicare AdvantageDelta Dental PPODelta Dental Premier
The practice accepts dental insurance and notes that insurance can cover up to 50% of orthodontic treatment costs. Patients without insurance are offered monthly payment plan options.

What patients say

Latest review 3 months ago

What patients praise

  • Reviewers frequently describe teeth going from misaligned to straight, with several calling the finished smiles a dramatic change.
  • Dr. Catherine Scheurer McDevitt is described as skilled with complex cases, including expander work and patients arriving mid-treatment from another office.
  • The practice schedules retainer checkups well after braces come off to keep results from shifting.

Who it suits

  • Families with several kids in treatment
  • Patients transferring mid-treatment from another office
  • Adults starting orthodontic treatment later in life

Doctors patients mention

  • Dr. Catherine Scheurer Mcdevitt · 12 reviews
  • Dr. Catherine · 27 reviews
Last 12 months
21 reviews
averaging 5.0★
Owner replies
45% of reviews
typically within 28 days
Reviews per month
22
Oct 2023Sep 2026
Reviews per month
Oct 20230
Nov 20230
Dec 20230
Jan 20240
Feb 20240
Mar 20241
Apr 20242
May 20248
Jun 20247
Jul 20242
Aug 20240
Sep 20240
Oct 20240
Nov 20241
Dec 20240
Jan 20250
Feb 20251
Mar 20250
Apr 20250
May 20253
Jun 20250
Jul 20250
Aug 20252
Sep 202522
Oct 20257
Nov 20250
Dec 20252
Jan 20261
Feb 20262
Mar 20260
Apr 20262
May 20261
Jun 20260
Jul 20261
Aug 20260
Sep 20260
Star ratings
  • 5★108
  • 4★0
  • 3★0
  • 2★0
  • 1★1
Average rating by year
  • 20135.0
  • 20175.0
  • 20185.0
  • 20195.0
  • 20205.0
  • 20233.0
  • 20245.0
  • 20255.0
  • 20265.0
1★5★
Treatments patients mention
  • Braces28
  • Invisalign / clear aligners6
  • Retainers4
  • Expanders & appliances3
What patients talk about
PraiseCriticism
  • Friendly staff42
  • The orthodontist31 / 1
  • Treatment results24 / 1
  • Great with kids21
  • Clear explanations16
  • Scheduling & wait times12
  • Gentle, comfortable care11
  • Cost, insurance & financing5 / 1
What patients talk about
ThemePraiseCriticism
Friendly staff420
The orthodontist311
Treatment results241
Great with kids210
Clear explanations160
Scheduling & wait times120
Gentle, comfortable care110
Cost, insurance & financing51

Advertisement

Claim your profile free to remove ads from this page.

Recent reviews from Google

5.0
105 reviews
Ahad Sarand
Ahad Sarand
2 months ago
“

My son and I had a great experience and were very pleased with the service. Dr. Catherine and her staff are highly professional, friendly, and made us feel very well cared for throughout our visit. I highly recommend Dr. Catherine’s office to anyone looking for excellent orthodontic care.

Review from Google

Lorenzo Ventresca
Lorenzo Ventresca
4 months ago
“

Dr. McDevitt and her staff are very friendly and flexible when it comes to scheduling! While my availability is generally limited due to school and work, they always are able to find a time that works well with my schedule! They also always keep me updated on any information on my upcoming appointments which is extremely helpful for me.

Review from Google

Hema Narayanan
Hema Narayanan
7 months ago
“

We are so glad we found Dr. Catherine for our child’s orthodontic care! From our very first visit, she was incredibly patient and took the time to explain everything in detail. After our initial review, she provided a clear cost breakdown and walked us through the exact timelines for the procedure, which we truly appreciate. There were no surprises - everything was pretty straightforward. She made my child feel completely comfortable before starting the procedure, which meant a lot to us as parents. Dr. Catherine is very detailed in her approach and truly a no-nonsense doctor in the best way possible. She's professional, clear, and focused on doing what’s right. She is always on time for appointments, which makes scheduling so much easier. The office is quiet, clean, and calm , no flashy distractions, just a well-run practice. She also has two amazing assistants who are very organized and follow up on appointments and schedules, even if you forget. If you’re looking for a skilled, straightforward orthodontist who values transparency and patient comfort, Dr. Catherine is the one. Highly recommend!

Review from Google

Zach Holbert-Watson
Zach Holbert-Watson
7 months ago
“

When my dentist recommended that I get braces in my mid-30s, I was anxious. Orthodontic treatment is known to be a lengthy process and has a reputation for being expensive and uncomfortable. But Dr. Catherine and her team are making it easy. The whole team has a welcoming attitude, and they've all been incredibly kind and gentle. Recognizing my own hesitation to commit to jaw surgery, Dr. Catherine presented me with several options and took care to thoroughly explain the pros and cons of each so I could feel confident in my decision. She takes the same patient, thoughtful approach every time I have a new question about the treatment process. She's also been very flexible, both with the treatment plan and the schedule. I can't recommend her highly enough.

Review from Google

Todd Newkirk
Todd Newkirk
8 months ago
“

All three of my children received their full orthodontic treatment with Dr. McDevitt with fantastic results. She and her staff are professional and flexible. Would highly recommend.

Review from Google

Read all 105 reviews on Google →

Questions about this practice

What orthodontic treatments does A Winning Smile Orthodontics offer?+
A Winning Smile Orthodontics offers: Invisalign, Early Treatment, Clear Aligners, Traditional Braces, Clear Braces, Retainers, Self-Ligating Braces.
Does A Winning Smile Orthodontics accept dental insurance?+
A Winning Smile Orthodontics accepts Aetna, Delta Dental Medicare Advantage, Delta Dental PPO, Delta Dental Premier.
Does A Winning Smile Orthodontics offer free consultations?+
Yes, A Winning Smile Orthodontics offers a free initial orthodontic consultation. Call (614) 888-8070 or book online to schedule.
Is A Winning Smile Orthodontics accepting new patients?+
A Winning Smile Orthodontics is currently welcoming new patients in Worthington, OH. Call (614) 888-8070 or book online to schedule.
Where is A Winning Smile Orthodontics located?+
A Winning Smile Orthodontics is located at 7100 N High St #105. Get directions: https://maps.google.com/?cid=18331152352937026534&g_mp=CiVnb29nbGUubWFwcy5wbGFjZXMudjEuUGxhY2VzLkdldFBsYWNlEAIYBCAA
What are the office hours for A Winning Smile Orthodontics?+
A Winning Smile Orthodontics office hours: Mon 9:00 AM–5:00 PM, Tue 9:00 AM–5:00 PM, Wed 1:00–5:00 PM, Thu 9:00 AM–5:00 PM, Fri 10:00 AM–2:00 PM, Sat 8:00 AM–12:00 PM, Sun Closed–Closed.
Does A Winning Smile Orthodontics offer payment plans?+
Yes, A Winning Smile Orthodontics offers flexible payment plans to make orthodontic treatment affordable.
Who are the orthodontists at A Winning Smile Orthodontics?+
A Winning Smile Orthodontics is staffed by Dr. Catherine Scheurer McDevitt. The practice is a member of the American Association of Orthodontists (AAO).
What is the patient rating for A Winning Smile Orthodontics?+
A Winning Smile Orthodontics has a 5-star rating based on 105 patient reviews on Google.

Research with AI

ChatGPTPerplexityClaude
7100 N High St #105
Worthington, OH 43085
Get Directions
(614) 888-8070
awinningsmileorthodontics.com/
Book Online
winningsmileorthodontics@gmail.com
Open in Google Maps
Accepting new patients
Free Consultation
Payment Plans Available
In-House Financing
Weekend Hours
Virtual Consultations
Online Booking Available
Emergency Hours Available

Accessibility & Parking

Wheelchair Accessible Entrance
Wheelchair Accessible Parking
Wheelchair Accessible Restroom
Free Lot Parking
Free Street Parking
CashCredit CardsDebit CardsContactless / NFC
Mon9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Tue9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Wed1:00 – 5:00 PM
Thu9:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Fri10:00 AM – 2:00 PM
Sat8:00 AM – 12:00 PM
SunClosed

Social Profiles

Google reviews synced
SOURCED

Claim your listing to update info, add photos, and respond to reviews. Claimed profiles are ad-free.

Are you the owner? Claim this listing
Back to Worthington Orthodontists

Nearby orthodontists in Worthington

Within 3 miles

Capital City Dental

4.9 · (513) · Columbus

Hutta Orthodontic Specialists

4.8 · (241) · Worthington · 0.4 mi

✓ Board certified · AAO member

Polaris Orthodontic Center

5.0 · (571) · Columbus · 3 mi

✓ Board certified · AAO member

View all Worthington orthodontists →
N
National OrthodonticRegistry

The nationwide directory for finding orthodontic care. 4,706+ practices across all 50 states.

Popular Cities

  • Los Angeles, CA
  • New York City, NY
  • Houston, TX
  • Chicago, IL
  • Phoenix, AZ
  • Miami, FL
  • Dallas, TX
  • Atlanta, GA

Browse by State

  • California
  • Texas
  • Florida
  • New York
  • North Carolina
  • Ohio
  • Arizona
  • Virginia
  • All states →

Discover

  • Find an Orthodontist
  • Invisalign
  • Cost Guides
  • Research
  • About Us
  • Contact

For Practices

  • Claim Your Practice
  • Verified Practice
  • Featured & Premium
  • Practice Login

© 2026 National Orthodontic Registry. All rights reserved.

PrivacyTermsllms.txt